This page explains how we choose, compare, and score outdoor gear for the United States market, so you can judge our recommendations for yourself.
How Products Are Chosen
We start with the products that are widely sold in the USA and relevant to the use case of each roundup — for example, tents for family car camping, not mountaineering. We list the candidates, check their published specifications, and read user feedback to spot recurring problems before any scoring begins.
How Products Are Scored
Each product is scored against the same criteria for its category. Scores are recorded only after the relevant checks have actually been carried out. We do not invent scores, and we do not present a score for a test that has not happened.
Weighted Scores
Not every criterion matters equally, so criteria are weighted by importance for the intended use. For example, weather protection may count more than packed size in a waterproof jacket roundup, while ease of setup may count more in a family tent roundup. The weights used for each roundup are published in that roundup, so the final order can be checked.
Example weighting structure (weights are set per roundup and published there):
- Core performance — the largest share of the total score.
- Ease of use and setup — a smaller, but meaningful, share.
- Durability and build quality — a smaller share, based on materials and construction.
- Value for money — a smaller share, comparing what you get for the price.
Note: no weighted scores have been published yet. Product slots in our roundups are marked as to be filled once testing is complete.
What We Do Not Claim
We only claim hands-on testing that actually took place. If a product has not been tested by us, we say so. We do not publish prices that we have not verified, and we do not copy test results or wording from other review sites.
Our Roundups
- Best Camping Tents
- Best Camping Lanterns
- Best Waterproof Jackets
- Best Outdoor Gear — the hub for all our outdoor gear guides.
Corrections
If you spot an error in a score, a specification, or a testing claim, tell us and we will check it and correct the page.